I really loathe this quote. It’s such a downer and so cynical - never mind that it’s so true. It doesn’t begin to lift my spirits or offer any hope. And hope is what we in the real estate world need, especially these days.
Whether or not you agree with the government’s October bailout program, it is, in fact, a reality. Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac are going to be working with delinquent homeowners to get them back on track so they can keep their homes. JPMorgan Chase & Co, Bank of America Corp and Citicorp are also falling in line to offer mortgage loan modifications to those who qualify.
Qualify - therein lies the rub.
The country is aware there are hundreds of thousands of homeowners in need of assistance who want to stay in their homes and be able to make their monthly mortgage payments. It would appear these lending institutions have laid out specific and clear criteria by which to judge whether applicants meet the standards for assistance. And as much as I’d like to think every applicant will be truthful about their housing situation, I’m reminded there are always “a few” who can spoil it for the rest. It even happened after the Twin Towers tragedy. Some people have no shame.
Here’s what Euro Pacific Capital investment manager Peter Schiff wrote in an e-mail last Tuesday:
“By offering to reduce mortgage payments to 38% of household income for homeowners who are 90 days delinquent, the mortgage program announced today will spark a new wave of delinquencies. In a classic case of unintended consequences, the plan will encourage homeowners to rearrange their finances to qualify for the benefit. Those who could conceivably economize to meet their existing obligation will now have a strong reason to forgo such sacrifices.
“The intentional reduction of income is also a possibility. In many cases dual-income families may decide to eliminate one job altogether as reduced mortgage payments combined with lower child care and other work-related expenses will likely exceed the after-tax value of the lost paycheck.
“It may also be tempting for some homeowners to temporarily quit high-paying jobs, or delay job searches, and accept low-paying jobs while the creditors consider their fate. Once their mortgage payments have been modified to fit their diminished incomes, these homeowners would then be free to pursue better-paying jobs. With mortgage payments reduced to a fraction of the prior payments, these workers will have much more employment flexibility than those foolishly struggling to meet non-modified mortgages.”
I’m not sure where Mr. Schiff is residing, but here in the state of Michigan, job-hopping is
not exactly an Olympic sport. A year ago I applied for a part-time clerical position, working two days per week, with no benefits. I got the position - and had to beat out 300 other applicants. I just don’t think people are going to give up a paycheck or work for less in order to qualify for a mortgage reduction. It seems far too risky to me.
Quitting a “high-paying” job, which more than likely includes medical benefits, sounds irresponsible and a little nutty. I’m not saying it won’t happen, but my hope is that if lenders have learned anything from this fiasco, it’s that close scrutiny of documentation and strict adherence to qualifications by borrowers must be in place.
Something had to be done. The bailout may not have been your first choice, but now that it’s been implemented, let’s try and have a little faith in humankind. Otherwise it really doesn’t matter what course of action is taken - failure of people to have integrity and faith in one another will be the demise of us all.
Posted by Sharon Walker























